Wall Street, Artificial Intelligence (A.I.), Hiring Trends, M&A, Talent

John Butler, Head of Insurance Investment Banking at Piper Sandler

On the first episode of Travillian Next: Investment Banking Edition, Dave Yancoskie, Managing Partner & Head of Investment Banking Search at Travillian, sits down with John Butler, Head of Insurance Investment Banking at Piper Sandler, to talk about what it takes to build an insurance investment banking team that people want to stay on. John has spent more than 25 years advising insurance carriers, brokers and service providers, after starting his career as a corporate securities attorney.

Dave and John get into the client-first approach behind Piper Sandler’s run as the No. 1 ranked U.S. insurance M&A advisor, the deal pipeline heading into 2027 and why John never bought into the idea that junior bankers are temporary employees. They also cover how his team hires (and why the interview alone isn’t enough anymore), what keeps bankers from leaving and how AI will change the work. John’s answer on developing the next generation of bankers might be the most reassuring one Dave has heard.

Listen Here: Spotify | Apple Podcasts

Episode Breakdown: Building an Insurance Investment Banking Team That Lasts

00:00 – Welcome to the Investment Banking Edition

Dave Yancoskie opens the first interview of Travillian Next: Investment Banking Edition, the new channel from Travillian’s FIG & Fintech investment banking search practice. His first guest is John Butler, Head of Insurance Investment Banking at Piper Sandler. Dave sets the theme early: continuity, a word he comes back to throughout the conversation.

00:43 – From Securities Attorney to 25 Years in Insurance Banking

John walks through a career that started in corporate securities law, doing M&A and public securities work. He moved into investment banking more than 25 years ago and has focused on insurance the entire time, covering carriers, brokers, agents, MGAs and service providers. For close to two decades he has been with Piper Jaffray, Sandler O’Neill or Piper Sandler, which gives his insurance investment banking group unusual continuity.

01:34 – The Numbers Behind Piper Sandler’s Insurance Group

Dave runs through the team’s league table record, including its standing as the No. 1 U.S. insurance M&A advisor by number of deals since 2012. He then asks John to name the one thing behind that sustained success. John’s answer is simple, and he explains why staying focused on it has set the group apart from firms distracted by internal noise.

03:11 – The Outlook for 2026 and 2027

John shares his read on the insurance M&A market for the rest of 2026 and into 2027. He expects a busy fourth quarter and talks about the challenge of getting deals done as more businesses come to market. He also explains why he thinks momentum will carry into the first half of 2027.

04:12 – Continuity and Growing Talent from Within

Dave shifts to his own wheelhouse: the human capital behind the results. He notes how rarely bankers leave John’s team, and how many have grown from analyst to managing director. John explains why the group builds talent organically, how that protects culture and how selective the team is when it does hire senior bankers, like Alex Ring.

06:12 – Rethinking the Two-Year Analyst Model

Dave asks what in John’s own background made him put so much weight on culture and development. John draws on his years as a junior banker and his view from outside the industry. He shares why the traditional two-year analyst model always struck him as odd, and what his team does differently when it spots long-term talent.

09:45 – Hiring Junior Bankers: More Art Than Science

With analysts, associates and even VPs, the recruiting process is often more art than science. John describes his team’s interview process, the role referrals play and why looking beyond the resume matters more than ever. He also explains how AI is changing what candidates can bring into an interview.

11:42 – Hire Slow, and Expect Some to Leave

John talks candidly about losing analysts and junior associates to private equity, which he calls flattering and annoying at the same time. He explains why some of those departures turn into long-term benefits, including bankers who come back. Dave adds how those relationships tend to return as clients and partners.

12:48 – Running a Process Candidates Remember

Dave shares what Travillian sees in insurance, the most competitive hiring market in its FIG & Fintech practice, and why over-communication matters. John explains how he wants every candidate to walk away from his team’s process, whether or not they get an offer. Dave adds why reputation in hiring travels faster than ever.

15:31 – What Keeps Bankers Happy

Dave asks what John does on purpose to keep his people from leaving, especially with recruiters calling. John describes what this generation of bankers wants and how his team structures feedback so it lands. He explains why some feedback should come from a vice president rather than from him.

17:29 – Rapid Fire

Dave asks a round of one-sentence questions. John covers how managing bankers has changed, what it takes to develop a young banker into a calling officer and the skill insurance investment bankers will need in 2030. He also names the habit he thinks other groups underestimate in his team.

18:30 – AI and the Insurance Investment Banking Business

John gives his prediction for how AI will change the industry over the next one, five and ten years. He argues the real question is what firms do with the time AI frees up. He also explains why the data behind all that deal activity could separate the winners from the losers.

21:46 – Developing the John Butlers of the Future

Dave raises the question on many junior bankers’ minds: if AI takes over the lower-level work, how will the next generation learn the fundamentals? John looks back on his own early days and lays out what he thinks will and won’t change. Dave calls it the best answer he has heard to that question.

25:18 – Wrap-Up

Dave thanks John for being the first guest of the Investment Banking Edition. John closes by thanking Dave and Travillian for their support of Piper Sandler and the insurance group.


Get in Touch with Dave!

Want to talk about building your investment banking team, hiring junior or senior bankers, or keeping the talent you have? Reach out directly:

Dave Yancoskie

Managing Partner & Head of Investment Banking Search, Travillian

Email DaveCall (610) 724-0645Connect on LinkedIn

Tags: Wall Street, Artificial Intelligence (A.I.), Hiring Trends, M&A, Talent

Subscribe to Travillian Next

Conversations on banking, talent, technology and leadership, delivered straight to you.

You May Also Like

Avi Upreti, Principal, AI Strategist at Hebbia
Your Deposits Have Commitment Issues: The Economy’s Humming, So Why Is Money Walking Out the Door?